Showing posts with label crime and punishment. Show all posts
Showing posts with label crime and punishment. Show all posts

Saturday, August 11, 2012

WHICH IS MORE BARBAROUS & INHUMANE, FLOGGING OR MINIMUM MANDATORY PRISON SENTENCES?

Are there any alternatives to long minimum mandatory prison sentences that ruin lives? Last year your favorite Clearwater Criminal Defense Lawyer suggested that defendants confronted with prison terms could be given the choice of prison time or a public flogging.
Now a philosophy blog looks at alternate punishment and finds that flogging might not be as inhumane as years of interminable lost time spent in prison. He notes that the long prison sentences are ineffective because people lack enough imagination and insight to fully comprehend how it would feel to lose one's freedom for years within a prison. Here are some excerpts from The Philosopher's Beard: Why prison doesn't work and what to do about it:
Is public flogging better than mandatory minimum sentence in Clearwater, Largo & Tampa, Florida
Public Flogging in the 1900s
Prison time is a very severe punishment. JS Mill likened it to being consigned to a living tomb. Any society that employs it should do so with care and restraint... Aside from failing in humanity, prison does not even perform well at the specific functions of a criminal justice system, namely, deterrence, retribution, security, and rehabilitation. We need to reconsider our over-reliance on prison, and reconsider whether other types of punishment, including capital and corporal punishment, may sometimes be more effective and more humane.
The fundamental problem with prison time, as Mill notes, is that its severity is hard to imagine... It is hard to imagine quite how it must be to be confined to a small space and narrow routine for periods of years, or even until death. There is no great drama to focus on. No particularly terrible things happen. Just more of the nothing...
A punishment that is hard to imagine will not work very well. First, people contemplating breaking the law will not be especially deterred by dread of the punishment... When one considers the advantages of flogging more generally one can see that it measures up well against prison time, especially longer prison sentences (more than a year). Its drama makes it much easier to imagine, indeed to over-imagine, and so it should work better than prison as a deterrent. For the same reason, it also seems better able to satisfy legitimate demands for retribution by those who have been wronged...Yet, unlike prison, achieving this effect doesn't require that large chunks of a person's life be thrown away, together with their relationships and mental well-being. Thus, exactly because of its barbarism, flogging seems a more efficient punishment because the total suffering it inflicts is less. In my view, that makes it more humane.
Me, just bring in a doctor with a large enough needle - the sight of that will be enough to keep your Clearwater Criminal Defense Attorney  crime-free for years.

Thursday, September 29, 2011

HERE'S YOUR CHOICE: FIVE YEARS IN JAIL OR SUBMIT YOURSELF TO A PUBLIC FLOGGING


Excerpt: For most of the past two centuries, at least in so-called civilized societies, the ideal of punishment has been replaced by the hope of rehabilitation. The American penitentiary system was invented to replace punishment with "cure." Prisons were built around the noble ideas of rehabilitation. 
If you were sentenced to five years in prison but had the option of receiving lashes instead, what would you choose? You would probably pick flogging. Wouldn't we all?
I propose we give convicts the choice of the lash at the rate of two lashes per year of incarceration. One cannot reasonably argue that merely offering this choice is somehow cruel, especially when the status quo of incarceration remains an option. Prison means losing a part of your life and everything you care for. Compared with this, flogging is just a few very painful strokes on the backside. And it's over in a few minutes. Often, and often very quickly, those who said flogging is too cruel to even consider suddenly say that flogging isn't cruel enough. 
My defense of flogging—whipping, caning, lashing, call it what you will—is meant to be provocative, but only because something extreme is needed to shatter the status quo. We are in denial about the brutality of the uniquely American invention of mass incarceration. 
America now has more prisoners, 2.3 million, than any other country in the world. Ever. Our rate of incarceration is roughly seven times that of Canada or any Western European country. Stalin, at the height of the Soviet gulag, had fewer prisoners than America does now (although admittedly the chances of living through American incarceration are quite a bit higher). We deem it necessary to incarcerate more of our people—in rate as well as absolute numbers—than the world's most draconian authoritarian regimes. Think about that. Despite our "land of the free" motto, we have more prisoners than China, and they have a billion more people than we do.
All this because we've taken a traditional punishment such as flogging out of the arsenal. We've run out of choices, choices desperately needed if we're to have any hope of reducing our incarceration rate by 85 percent, back in line with the rest of free world, back to a level we used to have. Faced with the choice between hard time and the lash, the lash is better. What does that say about prison?