Showing posts with label actual innocence. Show all posts
Showing posts with label actual innocence. Show all posts

Tuesday, January 05, 2016

WHY OUR CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM TOLERATES UNFAIR RESULTS EVEN FOR THE INNOCENT


In American criminal law is it possible to have justice without fairness? The unambiguous answer from our United States Supreme Court could be viewed as almost un-American. After all how can there be justice unless it is laced with fairness?

Yet our Court has often ruled that for expediency, also known as judicial economy, proof of absolute innocence - even for a defendant facing serious consequences such as the death penalty - is not sufficient reason alone for the Court to address a case.
Even this cold Lady Justice
is presumed innocent till proven guilty.

Thinking about the lawful definition of justice in America today leaves little room for questions of fairness. Instead the Court looks to finality. The need to always be moving forward with an ever lengthening line of criminal cases persuades the Court that each case must be resolved within its given framework of available time. When the clock runs out, the sentence stands for all time, innocence be damned. The prevailing law for criminal justice in our country is justice as convenience rather than justice as fairness.

And that makes the occasional call for fairness from a defendant's family member years after some obvious abuse easy for the criminal justice system to simply brush aside. The likelihood of success in opening a long ago closed case becomes a game of finding some method to lever the case open. It has nothing to do with guilt nor innocence. 

An example of the quality of leverage required to reopen a change of plea would be finding proof thru the Court Reporter's transcript of proceedings during the change of plea that the judge failed to ascertain if the defendant was affected by medication during the process of the plea. Other examples that could result in a plea being overturned would be incompetent counsel or not knowing the English language. In Florida most judges read questions and await responses with further probing questions when in doubt about the integrity of a plea with the goal of making certain that someone who pleads fully understands what he is doing as well as the consequences of the plea. 

If there was a trial by jury and the appeals process has run its course, then the chances of finding some lever to reopen a case are even more remote. Clearly once a person is found guilty there can no longer be any presumption of innocence. Unfortunately arguments based on fairness such as one that the defendant is actually innocent will be of little use. Allegations of unfairness and even proof of innocence will not likely to change the result of a criminal case. All of this means that the best chance for success in any criminal case is at the beginning. 

Monday, December 17, 2012

STUNNING FEDERAL JUSTICE FAILURE: DEFENDANTS REFUSE JURY TRIALS BECAUSE THE GAME IS RIGGED

The United States Sentencing Commission has just published a complete overview of all Federal Criminal Cases for the Fiscal Year which makes for entertaining reading for your favorite Federal Criminal Attorney. 

Prisoners in the Federal System are pleading guilty rather than going to trial because judges do not have discretion to give fair sentences  in Tampa Bay, Florida and thru out the country.
Van  Gogh, Prisoners Round, 1890
The report notes that over 96% of federally indicted Americans plea guilty rather than go to trial; but  those writing the report indicate that's not a problem because that's how it's been for ten years. 

The truth is Americans indicted by Grand Juries plead guilty because they believe the system is rigged. Are they right?


Rather than keep you in suspense here are some of the interesting nuggets from the Commissions Report, then we'll look at why so many Americans choose guilty pleas with long prison terms rather than risking trial by jury:
The vast majority of convicted defendants plead guilty. In fiscal year 2011, more than 96 percent of all offenders did so, a rate that has been largely the same for ten years. When offenders pled guilty, 44.0 percent received a sentence below the applicable sentencing guideline range, either at the request of the government, at their own request, or initiated by the court. Approximately 61 percent (61.5%) of these below range sentences were requested by the government, usually because the defendant had provided substantial assistance to the government or had agreed to have his or her case handled as part of an early disposition program.
Clearly the classic adversarial criminal court system has broken down when it comes to Federal Criminal Cases. Defense lawyers and their clients are unwilling to test the strength of the Government cases at trial. There are a number of reasons for the trend toward ever greater plea bargaining.
First, one could argue that most Federal cases are the result of better investigative techniques than typical criminal cases from the State of Florida, with the Feds simply amassing much more firepower aimed squarely at a Defendant. The Feds fight with more funding, more time and better educated, more experienced law enforcement officers who often graduated from doing smaller state investigations. 
Yet the Feds often get it wrong. Recently we've seen the expanding scandal of failed FBI forensics laboratories leading to unacceptable convictions of the innocent, as well as 28,000 flawed hair and fiber cases, failed DNA cases and other flawed evidence in which Federal Laboratories proffered wrong expert testimony and expert analysis in American Courtroom. What about the thousands of innocent Defendants who were persuaded to plea because it was the best deal they could get and the Defense Lawyers, instead of believing in their clients' innocence believed the faulty evidence to be reliable. The result is an unconscionable verdict of failing justice in the Federal Criminal Justice System.

Another reason there are high plea percentages in Federal cases is the severity of the Federal Sentencing Guidelines in which a conviction will mean years spent in the vast Federal Prison System. But years will be spent even if there's a plea of guilty, as the Sentencing Commission's Report notes that the average Federal sentence last year was over five years in prison.

Neither of these reasons should hinder such a high number of American Defendants from waiving their constitutional right to jury trials. Unless that is, they find that the game is rigged. 
From my experience in the Middle District of Florida in Tampa it's clear that sentences are usually severe even when there is a plea bargain that results in a plea agreement. 
This is true because the Sentencing Guidelines only grant a three level departure for acceptance of responsibility coupled with a few more levels down if the Judge finds that there's co-operation based on a 5K, but the Federal law requires that the Prosecutor file a Motion for Downward Departure based on substantial assistance otherwise the Judge can not look at co-operation for sentencing departures.
Ultimately the reason there are over 96% of pleas of guilty in Federal Cases is that our system is no longer fair. What happened?
The Federal Sentencing Guidelines have taken too much of the discretion away from our sentencing Judges and given it to Prosecutors. Prosecutors easily manipulate the grand jury to re-indict when there is no plea. Despite the work of Clearwater Criminal Defense Attorneys Prosecutors use the Sentencing Guidelines as leverage to force guilty pleas even when evidence is weak or where the facts and circumstances of the case do not exclude the possibility of actual innocence.


Sunday, December 16, 2012

INNOCENT MAN SPENDS 28 YEARS IN PRISON FROM FLAWED FBI ANALYSIS MISTAKING DOG HAIR AS HUMAN

Clearwater Criminal Defense Lawyers are often astounded at the manufactured evidence that expert witnesses testify to while being cross-examined during trial which leads to needless convictions of people who are later proven innocent. Testimony from witnesses of agencies such as the FBI are given great weight by Jurors during trial and by Judges during sentencing.
Matisse in striped jail shirt what would he think of a man spending 28 years in jail for a murder he did not commit, in Tampa Bay Florida there are many innocent people languishing in the Pinellas Jail.
Matisse, Self Portrait Jail Shirt, 1906

Yet forensic laboratory evidence from the FBI has been found to be tainted, unreliable and based on flawed forensic techniques in polygraph cases, fingerprint cases, DNA cases and handwriting cases. Often courts even in Florida will allow expert lab reports to be read to a jury without allowing cross examination of the expert who wrote the report. 


The Washington Post notes that American Courts are reviewing questions of innocence in over 21,000 cases of failed expert testimony and lab results just from the FBI's hair and fibers unit. The startling numbers have even more impact when you consider the actual lives destroyed. 
Santae Tribble spent 28 years of his life in prison for a murder he didn't commit. New DNA tests established that the 'expert' testimony and evidence from the FBI matching his hair to that of hair found at the murder seen was wrong. In fact the FBI examiner even failed to find that some of the hair examined belonged to a dog. 

The Judge signed a Certificate of Innocence stating that the Trial results must be vacated and the Post gives some insight into why:
A hair match also was critical evidence at his trial...Hair analysis was subjective and lacked scientific research into how often hairs of different people might appear to match, and the FBI lab lacked protocols to ensure that agent testimony was scientifically accurate.
The FBI agent testified at trial that the hair from the stocking matched Tribble’s “in all microscopic characteristics.” In closing arguments, the federal prosecutor went further: “There is one chance, perhaps for all we know, in 10 million that it could [be] someone else’s hair.” 
Court ordered DNA testing by a private lab confirmed that none of the 13 hairs retrieved from the crime scene shared Tribble’s genetic profile.  
One came from a dog; facts over which the FBI-trained examiners disagreed or missed outright at the trial.
The exploding scandal in forensic laboratories undermines American Justice. But so does the method by which the lab results were used. As often happens in Criminal Trials, the Federal Prosecutor argued far beyond the actual evidence in the closing argument. Isn't this a clear example of prosecutorial misconduct?

Yet worse where is the voice of our United States Supreme Court on one of the most important issues of our time, that goes directly to America's standards of justice, due process and fairness - the convictions of those who are actually innocent. 
Here's Justice Scalia taking the other Justices to task for taking a Defendant's actual innocence into account in Murder Cases:
This Court has never held that the Constitution forbids the execution of a convicted defendant who has had a full and fair trial but is later able to convince a habeas court that he is “actually” innocent.   
Quite to the contrary, we have repeatedly left that question unresolved, while expressing considerable doubt that any claim based on alleged “actual innocence” is constitutionally cognizable.
A Clearwater Criminal Attorney would remind Justice Scalia over a bottle or two of wine that when it comes to 'actual innocence' in criminal cases, the Supreme Court's first duty is finding Justice.