Showing posts with label Florida Highway Patrol. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Florida Highway Patrol. Show all posts

Monday, February 04, 2013

WHAT INCENTIVES DO LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICERS HAVE TO COMMIT PERJURY IN CRIMINAL CASES

Your favorite Clearwater Criminal Lawyer has watched with bated breath in numerous criminal trials as hundreds of officers have lined up one by one to testify against my doomed clients. Upon taking the witness stand having sworn to tell the truth they've done everything possible to convince those once fair and impartial jurors to convict. Were those officers always telling the truth?

Manet painting of wight. The man in the painting looks like a law enforcement officer who has just committed perjury in Tampa Bay criminal courtroom B under cross-examination
Manet, Considering Perjury, 1875
It's not uncommon to know that an officer is committing perjury especially when other evidence directly establishes that the officer is simply lying. 
Should the Jury, well and truly try and true, believe that libelous video that seems to show the officer beating all hell out of my client or the trustworthy officer's testimony? And yet the prosecutor will always ask the jury this, "Why would a law enforcement officer ever risk his career to lie under oath about a criminal case?" 
A recent editorial by Michelle Alexander in the New York Times addresses the issue of why officers lie under oath giving some good reasons as to why it happens more often than we think. The article quotes the San Francisco Police Commissioner as follow:
“Police officer perjury in court to justify illegal dope searches is commonplace. One of the dirty little not-so-secret secrets of the criminal justice system is undercover narcotics officers intentionally lying under oath. It is a perversion of the American justice system that strikes directly at the rule of law. Yet it is the routine way of doing business in courtrooms everywhere in America.”
The article mentions the unrelenting pressure to make ever greater numbers of arrests as a significant cause of police perjury. In many police departments the quality of an officer's work is judged based on the number of arrests he makes. 
Here in Tampa Bay the Largo Police Department and the Florida Highway Patrol have the reputation of going to extraordinary lengths to persuade their officers that the only path to advancement is with high arrest numbers causing some officers to speak up about the unrealistic pressure of the quota systems, even as the police agencies deny there is a quota system.
A second cause could be called the War on Drugs Syndrome. This seems to be what has long afflicted the Pinellas County Sheriff's Office in Tampa Bay, Florida who broke the law during investigations of significant drug cases, such as manufacturing marijuana.
The internal thinking of officers must be something along the lines of, "It's a war after all. It's us versus them. They're violating the law. We're the good guys." And the next thing you know Deputies are acting like criminals themselves lying under oath, lying to gain entry into a home or even destroying evidence.



Wednesday, April 18, 2012

TAMPA BAY POLICE SHOULD LEARN FROM BRITISH FORENSICS TEAM THAT SAVED BLIND LADY'S GOBSMACKED NOVEL OVER LUNCH

What was your last interaction with a police officer in Tampa Bay? Probably a speeding ticket. Possibly something worse. My last interaction went surprisingly well. I popped a contact lens directly onto the floor while going thru the electronic metal detector at the entrance of Court in Tampa. And to my surprise the officers would not let me leave until they'd found it. That's exactly what we want from our officers - a little help, understanding and enthusiasm. 
If law enforcement officers want more than to be feared or loathed, they must do good things, not just spy on us then lie to us as the Pinellas County Sheriff's Department's Drug Squad has admitted doing nor by mindlessly handing out hefty driving tickets as the Florida Highway Patrol and Largo Police Department are well known for doing with ugly quota systems upon which the best honest, hard-working officers who refuse to give enough tickets are fired or demoted. What are PCSO Deputies, Florida Highway Patrol and Largo Police Officers doing to earn our respect? And at least one Clearwater Criminal Defense Attorney can tell you that not one of them has helped him find all his missing reading glasses  - oh, the shame of it!
Recently in England a team of forensic officers gave up lunches over five months to help a blind lady recover a written manuscript for a book. It was only when she asked her son to read the book, that she found she'd used a pen that had long since run out of ink, according to The Telegraph:


John Millais,The Blind Girl, 1856
 Miss Vickers said she was “gobsmacked” when Dorset police officers agreed to help by sacrificing their lunch hours over five months to study the indents made by her pen.
“I could remember the gist of what I had written but there was no way I could have written exactly the same way again,” she said. “I am so grateful. It was really nice of them and I want to thank them for helping me out.”
Miss Vickers, from Charmouth, near Lyme Regis, lost her sight seven years ago through diabetes and turned to her imagination for solace.
Here's some advice from a Clearwater Criminal Defense Lawyer to the police and deputies in Pinellas - find people to help and help them - the gobsmacked look on their faces when they realize you're not giving them a ticket will be more than enough to offset the loss of revenue and it will really brighten your day and theirs.

Saturday, September 17, 2011

ONLY IN FLORIDA: HEADLIGHT FLASHING -- IT'S ILLEGAL --- 2,400 HEADLIGHT SIGNALING TICKETS GIVEN

"The law does not content itself with classifying and punishing crime. It invents crime," from An Almanac, by Norman Douglas, 1945


Florida is certainly a beautiful paradise with breathtaking beaches, stunning sunshine, and a lack of humidity - well two out of three isn't bad - but alas, our Sunshine State is also one of the most innovative places on earth for the invention of crime. Wouldn't we all be better off if the governing folks up in Tallahassee would spend more time at the beach and less time making absurd laws? 


Recent articles from the St Petersburg Times (see Man sues Florida for right to flash headlights - St. Petersburg Times) note that the Florida Highway Patrol has given out over 2,400 tickets to drivers for Headlight Flashing (see for definition and history: Headlight flashing - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia).


The absurdity of the law and how it is applied in Florida happily reaches even potential tourists in soggy sunless England. Below see an excerpt from an article from Britain's Daily Mail Newspaper (see Driver sues state of Florida after getting ticket for flashing lights to warn others of speed trap | Mail Online for the full text). Just don't tell them about the humidity...


A Florida driver is suing the state for wrongly issuing thousands of tickets to people who flashed their lights to warn other motorists of speed traps.
Erich Campbell says the act is not illegal and has filed a lawsuit on behalf of every driver fined for the violation over the past six years, accusing police of misinterpreting state law and violating motorists’ free speech rights.
'I don't like what the government is doing, especially now when most people have a hard time affording gas,' the 38-year-old told WTSP.com. 'And now they have to defend themselves against a made up charge that doesn't exist.'
Mr Campbell says the FHP trooper told him what he had done was illegal.
'You could tell in his voice he was upset,' Mr Campbell told WSTP.com. 'He was professional, he wasn't rude, but you could tell he was irritated.'
'This is a pattern, and it has mostly to do with frustrated police officers who feel they were disrespected,' Mr Campbell told the St Petersburg Times. 
'When someone comes along and rats them out, they take offense to it.'
Captain Mark Welch, a spokesman for the FHP, cited to the St Petersburg Times a law that says 'flashing lights are prohibited on vehicles' except for turn signals.
But soon after Mr Campbell launched his case against the state, the Highway Patrol ordered all troopers to stop issuing tickets to motorists who use headlights as a signal to other drivers.
'You are directed to suspend enforcement action for this type of driver behavior,' said the August 29 memo from Grady Garrick, acting deputy director of patrol operations.
The lawsuit estimates that 2,400 motorists in Florida were cited for headlight-flashing between 2005 and 2010.


Ticket: Mr Campbell says motorists are being unlawfully punished by frustrated police officers who feel they were disrespected
Ticket: Mr Campbell says motorists are being unlawfully punished by frustrated police officers who feel they were disrespected






Areas of Practice for Robert Hambrick - Attorney in Clearwater, FL
Clearwater, Forida DUI, DWI & Drunk Driving Criminal Defense Attorney
Forida DUI & DWI Frequently Asked Questions - FAQ