Showing posts with label Federal Appeal. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Federal Appeal. Show all posts

Friday, December 02, 2016

THE NEW FEDERAL CRIMINAL PRACTICE BOOK FOR LAWYERS, DEFENDING A FEDERAL CRIMINAL CASE

I've gotten my greedy hands on the latest 2016 edition of Defending A Federal Criminal Case by the Federal Public Defenders of San Diego priced at $399.00 for three volumes. It is - as were the previous editions of this book - a definitive legal guide for federal defense lawyers and something every defense lawyer should have in that arsenal of last resort, the firm's legal library where the Jack Daniels whiskey is stored. 

It also makes for for some heavy lifting in lieu of your gym membership that lapsed some time ago should you heft them all together and throw them in your briefcase to say, fight some battle in federal court. I suggest carrying large helium balloons to help carry the load. Though I suppose the makers of this fine edition have solved that potential problem by also providing the book as a searchable PDF download. For a limited time certified CJA defense lawyers may get the books free of charge, after that you'll need to burglarize the Middle District of Florida Federal Defenders Office or try to buy mine page by page if it comes to that.

So why is this set of books so useful for Federal Criminal Defense Lawyers? It covers everything from that federal arrest, to federal indictment, to federal bond hearing arguments, to an analysis of every major federal criminal violation, to federal trial and finally to that federal appeal you were hoping you'd avoid before that fatal federal verdict. Although these books were created in California they cite the latest law from a variety of Federal Jurisdictions especially where there are inconsistencies. This allows the user to not only have some ground level working knowledge of the relevant legal arguments from his or her jurisdiction, but some ideas as to the best standard arguments from more progressive parts of the country, which as we all well know is any place not part of the Eleventh Circuit.

The books are clearly a labor of love for the Public Defenders of San Diego, Inc who offer their cumulative years on how the federal criminal law is changing for a better idea of how federal criminal law is in actual practice now. In the best way these books are what you'd hope they'd be, a definitive voice giving unbiased advice for every step in a criminal case with the goal of always finding the best possible result for every issue.


Saturday, April 14, 2012

FALSE IMPRISONMENT OF LAWYERS IS NOT A FEDERAL CRIME OF VIOLENCE IN PINELLAS & TAMPA BAY


The Federal Appeals Court for the Eleventh Circuit, which has jurisdiction over federal cases in the Tampa Bay area, recently found that the crime of False Imprisonment, under Florida law is not always  a crime of violence. The designation of a prior as being or not being a crime of violence is important for federal enhancement of sentences under the Federal Sentencing Guidelines. 
In Rosales-Bruno, the Criminal Information upon which the Defendant was initially charged in the state of Florida case tracked the wording of Florida statute.Under Florida law a Defendant can commit a false imprisonment by merely "secretly confining" another person.


Your favorite Clearwater Criminal Defense Attorney often feels confined by having to listen to other lawyer's (and his own) interminable arguments in certain Courtrooms in Tampa Bay, does that count as false imprisonment?

Self-portrait of Pinellas False Imprisonment in Clearwater, Florida
Annibale Carracci, Self Portrait, 1604
The court held that secretly confining another person does not necessarily always rise to the level of "the use, attempted use or threatened use of physical force against the person of another." 
The prosecutor using Shepard documents attempted to establish that the crime was committed by the "use, attempted use or threatened use of physical force against the person of another." Yet the government was unable to effectively use the Shepard documents to meet its burden of proving that the prior offense was a crime of violence, so the Appeals Court reversed the sentencing Court's ruling to enhance the Defendant's sentence.
 The Government also argued in its appeal brief that at the sentencing defense counsel failed to adequately preserve the issue for appeal by properly objecting to the factual basis in the Pre-sentencing Report which described the prior False Imprisonment conviction in detail.  Although the Appeals Court held that the PSR paragraph detailing the prior was properly objected to at the sentencing; it's always important for a Pinellas Criminal Defense Lawyer to remember to timely object to any facts in the PSR which may be subject to a later appeal.

Thursday, October 27, 2011

AGGRAVATED IDENTITY THEFT - WARNING SIGNS YOUR LIFE HAS BEEN ABDUCTED FOR CONSUMERS IN CLEARWATER

Always be alert for these RED FLAGs of Identity Theft from your Federal Trial Lawyer:
  • You find that there exist accounts in your name which you never opened. 
  • You find purchases from accounts that you do not remember nor can explain.
  • You find purchases made to unknown companies, organizations or people.
  • You find inaccurate, flawed, incorrect or fraudulent information on credit reports on any information including any accounts or any personal information, such as the month, day or year of birth, your mother's maiden name, the name of your favorite pet (Sancho) your Social Security number, the spelling of your middle name, your present or past employers and the years you worked there.
  • You find that you are no longer receiving bills for credit cards or other debts, because the Identity Thief changes the address to which the bills are sent to cover his tracks.
  • You find that you have been sent a credit card for which you never applied and that my name is on it instead of yours.
  • You find that your credit rating has fallen, that you've been denied credit.
  • You find that you get voice messages, repeated debt letters from bill collection agencies, attorneys (damn them!), or from unique businesses concerning services, merchandise or priceless antique art work you could never afford and most likely didn't buy even if you were under the influence of drugs, alcohol or Antiques Roadshow.
If you may have been a vicim of identity theft in Clearwater, Florida and believe your information has been compromised this web page has information on what to do next.

As to the legal ramifications of identity theft here is a synopsis of yesterday's important 11th Circuit Federal Identity Theft decision:
United States v. John Doe, No. 09–15869 
( October 26, 2011) Appeal from the United States District Court for the Southern District of Florida John Doe (real name unknown at time of appeal) appealed his convictions for aggravated identity theft, claiming that the government did not produce sufficient evidence that Doe knew the name and social security number he used in applying for a United States passport belonged to an actual person. The Eleventh Circuit rejected this claim, noting that Circuit precedent stands for the proposition that a defendant's repeated and successful testing of the authenticity of a victim's identifying information prior to the crime at issue is powerful circumstantial evidence that the defendant knew the identifying information belonged to a real person as opposed to a fictitious one. Drawing all reasonable inferences in favor of the government, the Court found that a rational jury could have concluded that Doe knew the victim’s identifying information was subject to a detailed verification process when he applied for a driver's license. Doe's successes in obtaining not one, but two different driver's licenses from two different jurisdictions, in addition to opening a bank account and obtaining a debit card from Bank Atlantic, were meaningful circumstantial indicia that Doe knew the victim’s identifying information belonged to a real person, the Court wrote. 
The full text of the decision can be found here.
Bureau of Justice Statistics (BJS)
Internet Crime Trends
Good News & Bad News About Identity Theft

This unfortunate man was recently the victim of Identity Theft. Now he wonders around Europe trying to find out who it was he was meant to be while confronting mighty windmills.
File:Honoré Daumier 017 (Don Quixote).jpg
Honoré Daumier - Don Quixote - 1868 - Where's Sancho, my golden retriever?

Sunday, September 04, 2011

FLORIDA FEDERAL CRIMINAL DEFENSE ATTORNEYS SHOULD NOTE CHANGES FOR APPEAL BRIEFS

Many of the Clearwater Criminal Defense Lawyers and CJA lawyers may not be aware that on Monday, Aug. 1, 2011, the new appellate rules go into effect. Just when you think you understand them, the legal rules always change.

For Federal lawyer's who have an appeal it's always important to review the rules before you file a brief. There aren't many changes, mostly nuances and reorganization of the 11th Circuit Clerk's office.  Many appeals will either be based on an entire trial or will involve an appeal of the Federal Sentencing Guidelines or the way the Court interprets and applies the guidelines or the law itself such as an appeal on whether false imprisonment of lawyers is a violent crime under the federal law - it isn't.

One important change is the re-designation of the “Statement of Jurisdiction” section of the initial brief to “Statement of Subject-Matter and Appellate Jurisdiction.” 11th Cir. R. 28-1(g). This may sound trivial, but the Court likes procedural conformity, so it is a good idea to comply. For briefs filed on or after Monday, August 1, 2011, change the jurisdictional section in your template and now entitled it: "Statement of Subject-Matter and Appellate Jurisdiction." As per the contents of the jurisdictional statement, 11th Cir. R. 28-1(g) has been amended to note that the "jurisdictional statement must contain all information required by FRAP 28(a)(4) through (D)." 
Federal Rules of Appellate Procedure 28(a)(4)(A) through (D) specify that the jurisdictional statement include the basis for the district court’s jurisdiction {18 U.S.C. § 3231 in criminal appeals} and the appellate court’s jurisdiction {18 U.S.C. § 3742 in most sentencing appeals; 28 U.S.C. § 1291 in most other types of criminal appeals}, with citations to the applicable statutes and relevant facts establishing jurisdiction, the filing dates establishing the timeliness of the appeal, and an assertion that the appeal is from a final order or judgment. 

It's also important in grinding federal cases to never give up hope. Often federal defense lawyers seem beaten down by harsh results and the overwhelming complexity of the appeals process. Never forget the successes which federal appeals have brought countless defendants to restrict harsh unfair drug sentencing such as the crack to cocaine ratio as redefined by Congress and the Courts due to countless defense appeals from lawyers who never forgot simple plain fairness.