Showing posts with label DNA evidence. Show all posts
Showing posts with label DNA evidence. Show all posts

Wednesday, January 28, 2015

SIX FATAL FACTORS LEADING FBI AGENTS & POLICE TO DELIVER FALSE EVIDENCE IN CRIMINAL TRIALS

It goes without saying that evidence seized at a crime scene must be properly collected and thoroughly tested. But too often the FBI and FDLE (Florida's state-wide investigative agency) have bungled the process of collection and testing making a mockery of justice in Tampa Bay area courts. 


A hair match
FBI matched Hair Sample
Every Florida citizen should be able to rely upon the honesty and integrity of evidence gathered and tested by police departments. Yet for years FBI agents under oath in criminal courts were giving false testimony about evidence in hundreds of criminal cases. For example, in many cases FBI agents testified that hair samples were not just a likely match, but a definitive match for defendants when collected at crime scenes for high profile cases such as kidnapping, murder, aggravated batter, sexual battery, assault, arson or burglary. Yet later DNA testing, years after conviction, establish that the hair samples were not in fact a match. Only now, years later does the FBI admit that these agents were simply lying under oath.

Even many early DNA tests are known to be flawed. At the advent of DNA testing jurors were told emphatically that scientific tests established links that have become undone by newer, better DNA tests that establish no links in tested samples.

All of this should remind jurors, judges and prosecutors in pending criminal cases that science is not always right, and that even when science is correct, human error, lapses of judgment or a predisposition of the tester may invalidate the process. These flawed evidence cases often seem to emerge in the most gut-wrenching high profile cases - those in which police and prosecutors are under the gun to do everything possible to get a conviction, to get a believed perpetrator of a violent act off the streets. Instead of finding justice the real criminal commits further crimes while the justice system becomes of mockery of fairness.

Judges, prosecutors, defense lawyers and jurors should be aware of the following seven factors that often are in play in false evidence cases:

First, evidence is mishandled. The priority for any officer upon entering a crime scene is self protection. Is the perpetrator still at the scene? Is the perpetrator armed? Then the officer looks to find, protect and help any possible victim. Because the sanctity of the crime scene is not really their highest priority, it's not uncommon for the evidence to become mishandled. Yet few officers will admit as much even under oath at a criminal trial.

Second, evidence is mislabeled. Crime scenes are rarely as depicted in television. Often it's very chaotic, there may be blood strewn everywhere. There may be multiple possibilities of weapons. Any evidence with its location must be registered, bagged and logged. Yet often the evidence has been moved or is simply in such a mess by the time the agents in charge of handling it arrive, that proper labeling is problematic. 

Third, evidence is ignored. That rope under the bed, what could that possibly have to do with a stabbing? And if the evidence is never recovered or remembered it will never come into play. The defense attorney will not be given access to most crime scenes until long after it has been thoroughly cleaned.

Fourth, inconsequential evidence is given greater weight than it should. The value of evidence is based on how officers and prosecutors use it. It's not unusual in criminal cases for defense counsel to find that minor pieces of evidence are being used to trump up the type of criminal charge filed.

Fifth, evidence is improperly tested or misinterpreted. How is that labs continue to present flawed results? A lot of the problem is inappropriate contact between prosecutors, investigators and the testers in which testers are told what results are needed to convict. Testers should be blind to other information in the case that is not necessary for proper testing. The testing should conform to the scientific method in seeking the truth. The testing should be consistent. The testing should be retested and calibrated against other testers on a regular basis so that outliers are reduced. Further, jurors should be allowed to hear about other results from the laboratory which were flawed.

Sixth and most disturbing is prosecutorial misconduct in persuading law enforcement to fudge facts toward guilt by claiming plenty of other circumstantial and direct evidence of guilt.

Clearly, for the criminal justice system to work effectively in Clearwater, Florida every criminal defense lawyer must demand that sworn statements from police officers, FDLE agents and FBI agents are true and honest. And that the evidence they testify about is properly obtained, labeled, and unbiasedly tested. 

Thursday, July 26, 2012

DON'T LITTER - LITTERING LEADS TO MURDER CHARGE IN CLEARWATER FLORIDA

A man arrested man in Clearwater should have learned to never litter, because as Clearwater Criminal Defense Attorneys will tell you littering is often just the first small step to a murder charge.
Munch SelfPortrait with BurningCigarette...in Clearwater, Largo, St. Petersburg & Tampa, Florida a disgarded cigarette can be used to match DNA
Munch, Self-Portrait with Cigarette, 1895
 During a recent Pinellas County Sheriff's Office (PCSO) investigation into a grisly rape and homicide case police found DNA evidence on the victim's body as well as the mattress of her bed despite the fact that the perpetrator had cut out part of the bed sheet in an apparent attempt to remove incriminating evidence. The Sheriff's office even found a prime suspect, linked to the victim by videotape at a bar, but they had insufficient evidence to make an arrest. 
Was the DNA found at the crime scene a match for the suspect's DNA? 

To find out the Sheriff's Deputies followed the suspect. And finally while driving only a few blocks north of the apartment where the senseless crime occurred the Defendant made a mistake. He flicked his still moldering cigarette out the window. Deputies picked it up. Experts tested it and found a match to the DNA found on the victim. As your favorite Clearwater Criminal Defense Lawyer would happily tell you while drinking your best wine, no search warrant is necessary for personal objects which someone throws away because the act of discarding something shows that the person has forfeited his ownership interest in the property.

Tuesday, May 15, 2012

FABRICATED DNA CASTS DOUBT ON DNA EVIDENCE USED IN PINELLAS & TAMPA BAY FLORIDA CRIMINAL COURTS

We often think of DNA evidence as being infallible, but how reliable is DNA evidence in actual use? Even your favorite Clearwater Criminal Defense Lawyer would think twice about a conviction in Pinellas and Tampa Bay criminal courts that is based only on a DNA analysis, because errors can occur in the sample, in the testing and in the handling of DNA at the scene of a crime.
But here is some information for you that jurors never hear in any criminal trial in Pinellas and Tampa Bay from the testifying DNA experts of the Pinellas County Sheriff's Office or the FBI:


Scientists have demonstrated that it is possible to fabricate DNA evidence undermining the credibility of what has been considered the gold standard of proof in criminal cases. The scientists fabricated blood and saliva samples containing DNA from a person other than the donor of the blood and saliva. They also showed that if they had access to a DNA profile in a database, they could construct a sample of DNA to match that profile without obtaining any tissue from that person.  see DNA Evidence Can Be Fabricated, Scientists Show - NYTimes.com


Worse from the viewpoint of a Clearwater Crime Defense Lawyer, “You can just engineer a crime scene,” said Dan Frumkin, lead author of a paper by the journal Forensic Science International: Genetics. “Any biology undergraduate could perform this.” see Authentication of forensic DNA samples
DNA Profiling depends not only on accurate analysis but a database that is infallible and as you can see it also depends on the DNA being real. Are the FDLE and PCSO DNA analysts who testify in criminal trials in Pinellas and Tampa Bay courts familiar with the possibility that the DNA at a crime scene may have been manufactured? And if so, shouldn't they be telling these facts to Tampa Bay jurors without a Clearwater Criminal Defense Lawyer having to ask them?


Reliability weak points
Errors can occur if DNA samples are damaged or contaminated from improper handling. Limited amounts or mixtures of DNA profiles can increase misinterpretation of results.
Damaged
DNA sample
One case study
Houston Police Department Crime Laboratory
Houston shut its police crime lab's DNA division for several years after 2002 because of problems with the education and training of examiners, misleading testimony and improper evidence storage, leading to at least three exonerations and retesting of thousands of cases.