Yesterday, I finally received a late Pre-sentencing Report in a federal drug case from the probation office in Tampa. By law the Report must include, for the prosecutor's delight and the federal judge's perusal, the the cost of incarceration versus the cost of probation. As of yesterday the cost per year of federal incarceration is $29,291.62, whereas the cost of supervision by a probation officer is $3,162.03.
|Why send Sir John Falstaff to Prison?|
Think about those numbers. Think about the fact that the United States incarcerates a greater portion of it's population than any country on earth. How did this happen and what does it mean for our country? As these inmates age the financial impact becomes much greater forcing the federal Bureau of Prisons to become something closer to a nursing home of elderly prisoners.
A new DOJ study on aging inmates from it's own inspector general's office reinforces what we already knew - our American war on drugs is an abject failure not only for America but for the bureau of prisons. It turns out that thirty years of Federal minimum mandatory drug sentences have resulted in a prison population that is mostly populated by men over fifty years of age. Here is an excerpt from the report.
…the Federal Bureau of Prisons (BOP) incarcerated 164,566 federal inmates in 119 BOP-managed institutions.1 According to BOP data, inmates age 50 and older were the fastest growing segment of its inmate population, increasing 25 percent from 24,857 in fiscal year
The OIG found that aging inmates are more costly to incarcerate than their younger counterparts due to increased medical needs. We further found that limited institution staff and inadequate staff training affect the BOP’s ability to address the needs of aging inmates. The physical infrastructure of BOP institutions also limits the availability of appropriate housing for aging inmates. Further, the BOP does not provide programming opportunities designed specifically to meet the needs of aging inmates. We also determined that aging inmates engage in fewer misconduct incidents while incarcerated and have a lower rate of re-arrest once released; however, BOP policies limit the number of aging inmates who can be considered for early release and, as a result, few are actually released early.
For federal defense lawyers this study provides excellent arguments for requests to district judges at sentencing for sentence reductions and variances under the federal sentencing guidelines for older federal defendants. Clearly, the Justice Department now admits that Bureau of Prisons is incapable of handling the vast number of aged defendants yearly sent to federal prison.
Isn't it finally time for the DOJ, federal judges and Congress to do something about these inhumane sentences?